The 10 Best Creamy Soups You Can Make at Home to Warm Up Your September Nights

Look, I get it—you’ve probably read more than a few articles about creamy soups. But if you’ve ever endured a watery bowl that was all hype and no flavor, you know how disappointing they can be. The truth is, creamy soups are more than just a cold-weather food—they’re comfort, nostalgia, and satisfaction in one bowl.

After burning through too many failed recipes and overpaying for $12 café bisques, I’ve put together this list of creamy soups that actually deliver. These are the ones that belong on your September table and beyond.

1. Broccoli Cheddar Creamy Soup: The Childhood Trauma Healer

Broccoli cheddar is the gateway drug of creamy soups. Done right, it’s velvety, rich, and full of sharp cheddar flavor that makes vegetables taste indulgent. Forget the neon cafeteria version—this soup pairs beautifully with crusty bread and might just convert the pickiest eater in your family.

2. Loaded Baked Potato Creamy Soup: Because Regular Potatoes Are for Quitters

Loaded baked potato creamy soup is basically comfort food’s all-star lineup. Crispy bacon, sour cream, chives, and melted cheese turn a simple potato base into a bowl of pure joy. Sure, it’s not diet-friendly, but neither is stress, and this soup is infinitely more satisfying. Taste of Home’s list of creamy soups has plenty of cheesy variations worth exploring.

3. Chicken and Wild Rice Creamy Soup: The Sophisticated Comfort Choice

Chicken and wild rice creamy soup is what happens when comfort food grows up. The chewy texture of wild rice makes each bite interesting, while the creamy broth pulls everything together. Use rotisserie chicken to save time—it’s hearty enough to stand alone as a meal and elegant enough to serve to guests.

4. Tomato Bisque Creamy Soup: The Grilled Cheese’s Better Half

Tomato bisque creamy soup isn’t your average canned tomato bowl—it’s silky, balanced, and bursting with roasted flavor. Roasting fresh tomatoes brings depth you won’t find in shortcuts. Pair it with a golden grilled cheese sandwich, and you’ve got one of the most iconic creamy soups of all time.

5. Cauliflower Creamy Soup: The Vegetable That Finally Got Its Act Together

Cauliflower has stepped into the spotlight, and in creamy soup form, it shines. Blended until smooth and enriched with cheese or spices, creamy cauliflower soup is indulgent while still being sneakily healthy. EatingWell’s collection of creamy soups includes lighter takes that prove you don’t have to sacrifice flavor for nutrition.

6. Creamy Mushroom Soup: For the Fungi Fanatics

Forget the gloopy condensed cans—real creamy mushroom soup is luxurious, earthy, and deeply flavorful. Mixing varieties like shiitake, cremini, and oyster mushrooms creates a rich umami base that cream enhances perfectly. This is one of those creamy soups that proves simple ingredients can taste gourmet.

7. Clam Chowder Creamy Soup: The Coastal Classic That Actually Matters

When it comes to creamy soups, clam chowder is king. Thick and brimming with potatoes, clams, and cream, New England clam chowder is the definition of comfort. Even if you’re nowhere near the coast, a good batch can transport you straight to a seaside café.

8. Chicken Tortellini Creamy Soup: The Italian-Inspired Overachiever

Chicken tortellini creamy soup feels like two comfort foods collided—and the result is perfect. The pasta adds substance while the creamy broth ties everything together. Add spinach or carrots, and suddenly you’re serving one of the most versatile creamy soups around, ideal for weeknights or company.

9. Sweet Potato Creamy Soup: The Fall Favorite That Works Year-Round

Sweet potato creamy soup is like autumn in a bowl. Sweet, earthy, and spiced with cinnamon or nutmeg, it’s rich without being heavy. A splash of cream turns this into one of the smoothest, most photogenic creamy soups you’ll ever make—perfect for cozy September nights or Instagram bragging rights.

10. Cheesy Ham and Potato Creamy Soup: The Leftover Transformer

Turn leftovers into gold with cheesy ham and potato creamy soup. Smoky ham adds depth while potatoes make it filling enough to stand alone as dinner. This is the creamy soup you make when you want to curl up under a blanket and forget the outside world exists.

The Creamy Truth About Soups That Comfort

At their best, creamy soups are more than just meals—they’re therapy. They warm you when the air turns crisp, soothe you when life feels chaotic, and remind you that comfort can be simple. Whether it’s broccoli cheddar or clam chowder, creamy soups are proof that the most satisfying dishes don’t need to be complicated.

So grab your pot and your ladle. Once you’ve tried these creamy soups, you won’t waste time on watery imitations again.